"Giselle"
American Ballet Theatre
Metropolitan Opera House
New York, New York
June 17, 2014
by Mary Cargill
copyright © 2014 by Mary Cargill
Polina Semionova and David Hallberg in "Giselle"
Photo © Gene Schiavone
"Wonderful! Wonderful!" the man behind me shouted after almost every variation during the Polina Semionova/David Hallberg performance of "Giselle". He certainly had a point. Seminova is a tall, long-limbed dancer, not a typical Giselle, but she controlled her extremes to present a fully developed character; a ballerina, it seems, is someone who can do anything but has the taste not to. Her first act Giselle was a shy, happy girl surrounding a spine of steel. She was devoted to Albrecht, throwing herself in front of Hilarion to protect her lover without the gentle sympathy for the rejected suitor that some Giselles have. Albrecht was her whole world, and everything she did was for him. I loved the little impetuous gesture she gave her friends to clear the way so she could dance while he was watching, and the desperate concern she showed when her weak heart might make Albrecht unhappy. This complete devotion made her mad scene so understandable, since she clearly couldn't live without him. She had a quiet but intense breakdown, still and broken and could barely lift her arms to pluck the imaginary daisy.