"Mes Oiseaux", "Liebeslieder Walzer", "Symphony in C"
New York City Ballet
The David H. Koch Theater
Lincoln Center
New York, New York
May 19, 2012
by Mary Cargill
copyright © 2012 by Mary Cargill

Even in the pure-dance air of the New York City Ballet, costumes are important, and the recent triple bill showed a variety of dressings. The first ballet, Peter Martins' new "Mes Oiseaux", was dressed by the dress designer Gilles Mendel, and featured three girls (Lauren Lovette, Ashly Isaacs, and Claire Kretzschmar, all corps dancers) wearing chic black cut-out leotards over colored skirts. They were partnered by Taylor Stanley (another corps dancer) also wearing black. The costumes were simple and flattering, though the girls did without tights, making their legs look pale and knotty--this current trend is always unflattering. But bare legs were not the only issue. Dancers need something to dance, and "Mes Oiseaux" ("My Birds" in English), is a generic collection of unconnected steps which shows little about the dancers. Certainly Lauren Lovette has proved, in other roles, that she is distinctive and gracious dancer, but Martins has her do the same, twitchy steps as Isaacs and Kretzschmar, and it is impossible to tell what drew him to these particular dancers. Yes, they all have great extensions and fluid backs but appear to be completely devoid of personality. Stanley danced with all three dancers (the debt to "Apollo" is obvious), but, since he spent most of his time either hoisting them up by their crotches or dancing with his back to them, all he conveyed was a cool disregard for his partners, reinforced by the finale, which seemed to end in a shrug. His choreography looked like he had been tossed a bunch of moves, which in turn he tossed back at the audience.